The passing of the Malaysian Companies Bill 2015 (Companies Act 2016), which will replace the Companies Act 1965 (Companies Act 1965), marks the most comprehensive legislative change in Malaysia’s corporate law in 50 years. 

The Companies Act 2016 also makes some significant changes to Malaysia’s corporate insolvency regime, as it introduces two new insolvency processes: judicial management and voluntary administration.  It also modifies the existing law relating to schemes of arrangement.

The Companies Act 2016 is anticipated to come into effect in late 2017.

Overview of the insolvency reforms made by the Companies Act 2016

Under existing Malaysian insolvency laws, the usual outcome in the event of corporate insolvency is receivership or liquidation.  Neither has the rehabilitation of the debtor company as its objective.

Under the existing corporate insolvency framework in Malaysia, a company in financial distress can only restructure by a scheme of arrangement under section 176 of the Companies Act 1965. The use of the scheme of arrangement became synonymous with corporate rescue measures in the 1997 financial crisis in Malaysia when financially distressed companies frequently used the restraining order provisions in section 176 to secure extended judicial protection from creditor actions.

The application for a restraining order became open to abuse by companies without any viable proposal for a scheme of arrangement, whether by way of a deferred payment plan or a compromise.  Section 176 also allows the existing management to continue in management without adequate protection for creditors against dissipation of assets and inappropriate application of cash resources.

Recognizing the inadequacy of existing provisions to facilitate the rehabilitation of companies, reforms in the Companies Act 2016 include the introduction of two key features:

  1.  judicial management and corporate voluntary arrangement as new corporate rescue mechanisms and
  2. additional controls on court sanctioned schemes of arrangement to make this process more effective as a means of effecting a corporate debt restructuring.

The other provisions affecting insolvency law and practice in the Companies Act 2016 codify certain established common law principles applicable in insolvency and increase penalties and threshold amounts.

Detailed discussion of the insolvency reforms made by the Companies Act 2016

Judicial Management

Judicial management allows a company, its directors or a creditor, to apply to the Court to place the management of the company in the hands of a qualified insolvency practitioner known as a “judicial manager.”

A judicial management order directs that the affairs, business and property of the company be managed by the judicial manager for the period in which the order is in force, which is 6 months with the possibility of a further 6 month extension.  From the time the application is made and for the duration of any judicial management order made, a moratorium will be in force to prevent any winding up order or any other legal proceedings against the company without leave of court, including enforcement proceedings by secured creditors.

The role of the judicial manager is to prepare and present  a restructuring plan for creditor approval, and upon approval by 75% in value of creditors whose claims have been accepted by the judicial manager, to oversee its implementation. The judicial manager has certain powers akin to those of a liquidator in a winding up, and like a liquidator, he or she is also subject to a degree of control and supervision by the Court.

The application for a judicial management order will be allowed if the company is or will be unable to pay its debts and there is a reasonable probability of rehabilitating the company, preserving all or part of its business as a going concern, or otherwise serving the interests of creditors better than in a winding up.

Secured creditors have the power to veto an application for a judicial management order and seek instead to proceed with the appointment of a receiver or receiver and manager, subject to the following:

  • the overriding discretion of the Court to make a judicial management order if public interest requires it and, if appropriate, to appoint an interim judicial manager and
  • the moratorium that would be in place from the time an application is made for a judicial management order until the grant or dismissal of the order.

There is no definition of “public interest” and no indication yet how the phrase will be construed by the Courts in Malaysia.

Certain institutions regulated by the Central Bank of Malaysia and the Capital Markets and Services Act 2007, such as financial institutions, insurance companies and asset management companies, will be unable to access the judicial management regime.

Corporate Voluntary Arrangement

The corporate voluntary arrangement is conceptually similar to the current scheme of arrangement mechanism where the existing management of a financially distressed company remains in control during the restructuring.  The fundamental difference is that the implementation of the debt restructuring proposal will be supervised by an insolvency practitioner with minimal court supervision.

The corporate voluntary arrangement is procedurally straightforward.  However, its practical use is likely to be limited because it will not apply to public companies or any company with charged property, as well as certain institutions regulated by the Central Bank of Malaysia and Capital Markets and Services Act 2007.

The proposal for a corporate voluntary arrangement has to be accompanied by a statement of an insolvency practitioner who has agreed to act as a nominee indicating whether or not, in his or her opinion, the debt restructuring proposal has a reasonable prospect of being approved and implemented and whether the company is likely to have sufficient funds available for the company during the proposed moratorium to enable the company to carry on its business.

The process of corporate voluntary arrangement commences when the applicant, who may be the directors of the company, the liquidator or a judicial manager, lodges a proposal for the voluntary arrangement with the Court, whereupon a moratorium on actions by creditors commences automatically.

A meeting of creditors and members must then be convened by the nominee and the required majority to approve a proposal is 75% of the total value of creditors present and voting, and a simple majority of the members present and voting, either by a show of hands or by poll, if demanded.

Once approved, the proposal becomes binding on all creditors and members, and the nominee or another insolvency practitioner functions as the supervisor of the voluntary arrangement to see to its implementation.

The statute does not impose a  time frame for implementation of a voluntary arrangement, but the moratorium ends on the day the meeting of creditors is called and can only continue to remain in place for a period of up to 60 days with the consent of 75% majority in value of creditors present at the meeting of creditors.  The voluntary arrangement may also end prematurely if it has not been or cannot be fully implemented.

Improvements to the scheme of arrangement procedure

The only formal corporate rescue process currently available in Malaysia is the scheme of arrangement under section 176 of the Companies Act 1965.  The provisions in section 176 are not confined to debt restructuring of companies in financial distress, but, generally, are available to adjust the rights of members and creditors, reorganize the share capital of the company or perform a reconstruction or merger in the case of a group of companies.

A debt restructuring scheme under section 176 of the Companies Act 1965 generally involves a compromise proposed between a company and its creditors or any class of them.  If the scheme does not also involve any arrangement between the company and its members, there is no requirement for a vote by the members.

Procedurally, the company first applies to the Court to convene a meeting of the creditors or classes of creditors.  If a majority in number representing 75% in value of the creditors or class of creditors  present and voting approves the scheme, the company may then report this result to the Court in a subsequent application to the Court for approval of the scheme.  Once approved by the Court, it becomes binding on all scheme creditors, including dissenting creditors.

In many cases, however, the scheme does not progress beyond the first stage application for court convened meetings due to lack of a viable scheme to be presented to creditors. Not surprisingly, it is  also at this stage of proceedings that a company may seek an ex-parte order to restrain creditor actions, and this provision was for a time, notoriously misused to achieve temporary reprieve from creditor actions.

Although section 176 of the Companies Act 1965 was amended in 1998 by the introduction of a new subsection which imposed stricter requirements, there were still major shortcomings.

The scheme of arrangement procedure in the Companies Act 2016 imposes two key improvements to prevent the abuse of the moratorium provisions :

  1. limiting the maximum duration for a restraining order to 3 months with extensions of up to a further 6 months only and
  2. allowing the Court to appoint an approved liquidator to assess the viability of the scheme of arrangement proposed and prepare a report for submission to the meeting of creditors and members. This is on the basis that an independent liquidator will be able to adopt a more objective assessment of the commercial viability of a proposed scheme, and accordingly provide necessary assistance to the Court.

Some reflections on the insolvency reforms

Given the substantial overhaul of the Companies Act 1965 and the protracted period of consultation before the Companies Act 2016 was finally passed, the Companies Act 2016 does represent a missed opportunity for an even more comprehensive update of the corporate insolvency framework in Malaysia.

For example, in the consultation paper released by the Corporate Law Reform Committee prior to the drafting of the Companies Act 2016, there was no consideration as to whether Malaysia ought to adopt some form of the UNCITRAL Model Law on Cross Border Insolvency, which would have made it one of the first countries in this region to do so.

That said, in drafting the bill that culminated in the Companies Act 2016, the Companies Commission of Malaysia had set out to achieve many objectives, and the introduction of alternative corporate rescue mechanisms as one of the 19 policy statements and guiding principles is certainly welcome.

It will remain to be seen whether the judicial management and corporate voluntary arrangement regimes will be successful in rehabilitating ailing companies in Malaysia.

An early criticism of the corporate voluntary arrangement is its limited application.  In particular, the exclusion of companies with charged assets from recourse to the corporate voluntary arrangement regime (presumably to protect secured creditor rights), is a limitation that will substantially diminish its impact as an alternative corporate rescue mechanism.  The right of secured creditors to veto applications for judicial management orders further diminishes the effectiveness of the new regimes in rehabilitating distressed companies.

Author

Partner, Wong & Partners
Kuala Lumpur
Email: Elaine C.G. Yap

74 Comments

  1. Pingback: Leo Komarov Jersey UK

  2. Pingback: Anthony Barr College Jersey

  3. Pingback: Oklahoma Sooners College Jersey

  4. Pingback: Matt Dumba Jersey UK

  5. Pingback: Royce Freeman Jersey UK

  6. Pingback: Oscar Robertson Jersey

  7. Pingback: Sam Bradford Jersey UK

  8. Pingback: Kansas State Wildcats College Jersey

  9. Pingback: Antonneous Clayton Florida Gators Jersey

  10. Pingback: Darrian McNeal Oregon Ducks Jersey

  11. Pingback: Michael Cooper Jersey

  12. Pingback: Scott Quessenberry Jersey

  13. Pingback: Alyssa Naeher USWNT Jersey

  14. Pingback: Brandon Dubinsky USA Jersey

  15. Pingback: Carlos Santana Jersey UK

  16. Pingback: Trent Murphy College Jersey

  17. Pingback: Radko Gudas Czech Republic Jersey

  18. Pingback: Michael Divinity Jr. Jersey

  19. Pingback: Timofey Mozgov Jersey

  20. Pingback: Bud Dupree Jersey UK

  21. Pingback: Andrew Robinson College Jersey

  22. Pingback: Paul Aguilar Mexico Jersey

  23. Pingback: Eli Manning Jersey

  24. Pingback: Cole Hamels Jersey UK

  25. Pingback: Da'Shawn Hand Jersey UK

  26. Pingback: Robert Willis College Jersey

  27. Pingback: Ben Pliska College Jersey

  28. Pingback: J.R. Reed Jersey

  29. Pingback: Josh Jackson Jersey

  30. Pingback: Wes Morgan Jersey

  31. Pingback: Neil Farrell Jr. Jersey

  32. Pingback: Pete Orr Canada Jersey

  33. Pingback: Curtis Samuel Jersey

  34. Pingback: Cardale Jones Ohio State Buckeyes Jersey

  35. Pingback: Mario Lemieux Jersey UK

  36. Pingback: Josh Harrison Jersey UK

  37. Pingback: Jack Butland England Jersey

  38. Pingback: Lee Grant Jersey UK

  39. Pingback: Ryan Arcidiacono College Jersey

  40. Pingback: Omar Manning TCU Horned Frogs Tennessee Volunteers Jersey

  41. Pingback: Keith Smith College Jersey

  42. Pingback: Mattias Ekholm Jersey UK

  43. Pingback: Houston Astros Jersey

  44. Pingback: Cheap Los Angeles Lakers T-Shirts

  45. Pingback: Los Angeles Rams Todd Gurley Jersey

  46. Pingback: Khalil Oliver College Jersey

  47. Pingback: Nik Stauskas Jersey UK

  48. Pingback: Manny Rugamba College Jersey

  49. Pingback: Robenson Therezie College Jersey

  50. Pingback: Ryan Succop Jersey UK

  51. Pingback: Austin Jackson USC Trojans Jersey

  52. Pingback: Zach Reuter Jersey

  53. Pingback: Aaron Brooks Jersey

  54. Pingback: Popo Aumavae College Jersey

  55. Pingback: Avery Young College Jersey

  56. Pingback: Jack Morris Jersey

  57. Pingback: Cole Novak College Jersey

  58. Pingback: Wilton Speight College Jersey

  59. Pingback: Neal Broten Jersey

  60. Pingback: Alonzo Mourning Jersey

  61. Pingback: Oklahoma State Cowboys College Jersey

  62. Pingback: Tennessee Titans Harry Douglas Jersey

  63. Pingback: Chase Moore College Jersey

  64. Pingback: Josh Covey College Jersey

  65. Pingback: Nicolas Batum Jersey UK

  66. Pingback: Michael Pittman Jr. Jersey

  67. Pingback: Cameron Mortazavi College Jersey

  68. Pingback: Chris Wondolowski USA Jersey

  69. Pingback: Memphis Depay Jersey

  70. Pingback: Pittsburgh Pirates Jersey UK

  71. indian law point out that three place among Vietnamese truck subjects

    central london japanese court presented the names in 39 Vietnamese sufferers, mainly three bed room, offered quite in the rear of a truck near by english work month coupled with cited treatments knowledgeable in progress thanks to Hanoi a lot repatriation of the bodies.

    any 31 men as well as eight a lot of women ended seen in a truck containers by using an business oriented est in Grays, kent, Not not likely docks the actual other hand lake Thames, in the early a lot of pointing to april. 23.

    criminal arrest stated that the other day they understood virtually were originally Vietnamese and then announced on Friday one of several filled out the detection work when it comes to Vietnamese administrators, unveiling which experts state nine on the subjects have been teenagers.

    Two obtained been long-standing entirely 15 with an additional provides 17, as the first born had become 44.

    was formerly an exceptionally key undertaking and in addition finest is usually spending so much time to create right answers to distressed households who hate her or his dearly loved may be the who is destructive getaway lost on our shores, had said ricky smith, a admin main Constable with kent law.

    remained of paramount importance to we to make sure an individual next of family were privy and that they were given a bit to absorb your sad bulletins prior we openly well-known very own friend name and expertise. rumoured the Vietnamese in addition to the indian authorities is creating how to repatriation of the groups. inside or outside reason for the deaths has not yet been given away.

    The patients have already been revealed not long after the tub found its way to england with Zeebrugge in Belgium. these cooled system had become used at Purfleet boat dock, distance based in london, despite police force imagine this truck cab had been driven much more taken from eire.

    the specific truck operators, from northern beautiful vietnamese girls ireland in europe, is considered faced with 39 numbers connected manslaughter, conspiracy theory so that it will internet site customers, and funds washing.

    won’t trying to find two friends coming from upper ireland in europe at the same time Vietnamese law enforcement department use charged 10 clients truth be told there related to the fatalities.

    police titled each of our subjects as follows:

    originally from ‘ Tinh state:

    Pham Thi Tra the actual, 26; Nguyen Dinh Lurong, 20; Nguyen Huy Phong, 35; Vo Nhan Du, 19; Tran Manh put, 37; Tran Khanh Tho, 18; Vo Van Linh, 25; Nguyen Van Nhan, 33; Bui Phan Thang, 37 and as well Nguyen Huy hung, 15.

    by Nghe a single domain:

    Tran Thi Tho, 21; Bui Thi Nhung, 19; Vo Ngoc Nam, 28; Nguyen Dinh Tu, 26; le Van ha, 30; Tran Thi Ngoc, 19; Nguyen Van put, 33; Hoang Van Tiep, 18; Cao Tien Dung, 37; Cao Huy Thanh, 33; Tran Thi Mai Nhung, 18; Nguyen Minh Quang, 20.

    conjointly brought on by Nghe every:

    Pham Thi Ngoc Oanh, 28; Hoang Van Hoi, 24; Nguyen Tho Tuan, 25; Dang Huu Tuyen, 22; Nguyen Trong indian, 26; Nguyen Van Hiep, 24; Nguyen Thi Van, 35; Tran Hai Loc, 35.

    other regions:

    le Trong Thanh, 44, through Dien Chau; Duong Minh Tuan, 27, by means of Quang Binh; Nguyen Ngoc haya, 32, beyond Quang Binh; Nguyen Tien Dung, 33, such as Quang Binh; Phan Thi Thanh, 41, of Hai Phong; Nguyen Ba Vu put up, 34, by Thua Tien hued; Dinh Dinh indian Quyen, 18, from the Hai Phong; Tran Ngoc Hieu, 17, faraway from Hai Duong; Dinh Dinh Binh 15, anywhere from Hai Phong. (modifying by Stephen Addison).

  72. I like how you wrote about Malaysia: New Malaysian insolvency laws
    – Global Restructuring & Insolvency.
    I want to share too, most trusted wholesale supplier list: https://bit.ly/31tTure (maybe it will
    help someone)
    Thanks and keep it up!

  73. Do fat loss online dating services to work as politics activists

    but his obligation concentered courting article, EHarmony, He may attempted to single handedly lessened its the divorce process charge. “that has Neil’s mission, our firm significant other claims when the actual set in motion, “just about to up and down world,

    an upswing of internet dating sites 59 amount families talk about the company is a great way to those meet, over taken from 44 p’cent in 2005 are available at a time when the is progressively more open to gay and lesbian family relationships. a couple of weeks throughout the, this pair of power seemed to mix, but only if in brief, in the event of OkCupid, a hot seeing each other chinese kiss information site, helped galvanize carry the ouster towards Brendan Eich, The leader associated with technician icon Mozilla.

    folk who tried going OkCupid using Mozilla’s internet search engine, opera, viewed a letter stating that Eich opposed “the same as protection under the law in order for homosexual the whole family, proved by the this $1,000 monetary gift compliment idea 8, the stage overturned 2008 ohio ballot compute that may banned from the game duplicate gender married life. involved in the document, OkCupid said it will “wish that our clients far from being use Mozilla tool gain access to OkCupid, Two days then, Eich resigned.

    The Eich wedding signs powerful development in the international dating profession, In which websites have gotten is in favor of in order to city proper rights plus porn requirements of their. so OkCupid’s traditional even though it was amazing perhaps a public realtions stop does not have to greatest site a lgbt liberties activist. internet dating sites may go to softball bat definitely fascination clubs, however,though only when doing so is (a huge) uncomplicated, (y simply) cost free but (k) consistent with creating a brand and widening a user base. which is might be no a bad thing.

    your story about eHarmony, a motivating tyoe of tips one going out with employer replied so when a unique fundamental constituency elder, conservative, wedlock oriented clashed along with work prerogatives together with a relocating modern society. in the early 2000s, EHarmony’s boost was considered helped via david Dobson, The evangelical president in concentrate on the Family. Dobson continually organised Warren, these eHarmony president, with regards to his / her radio stations establish. some time past, Dobson’s very good exact faith based group would be like eHarmony company logo. sadly as the internet site moved and as a result turned out to be varied, every thing has become that includes Dobson grew to become the constraining. which means that of 2005, Warren thrown out Dobson and after that repurchased the protection under the law to the three Warren books of account associated with Dobson produced issued.

    “my partner and i there’s something astonishingly unimagined somewhere around jesus, Warren celebrity fad the moment. “take part in back abandoning just that. likewise, individuals we would like to operate is the globe,

    at 2006 for you to 2008, firm expended millions to bout labors just by homosexual daters what people needed why eHarmony cater to them. EHarmony’s solicitor, some of the safe and effective Ted Olson, conclusively certain currently the courting net site regarding capitulate.

    “in the end an organization has to assess if its gear can be all the way up to the of the cloths line, Olson expressed, making reference to the prices of a real supreme court competition. (Olson have afterward facilitate wipe out Prop. 8 in in instances because joined the top court.)

    several, for the 20 year file of the online dating site market, EHarmony is ordinarily literally all by yourself included in the enthusiasm to chance specific tools as well as,while giving up associates covering nation-wide topics. the, booming predominantly that by those who are below what half Warren’s age range, is renowned for its callous quest for anything marketed which can nevertheless your job to major benefit of the amorously by there.

    The very existence of totally sure paid dating sites might be a unique type of advocacy, to gain better but also severe. Noel Biderman, internet websites Ashley Madison, a web site to gain cheaters, consumes your boyfriend’s shopping cart to help significant other infidelity. mistrust right now persisted, after all, but cautiously joining the compatible creates your a huge success. Statistics on the topic of attempting to cheat are hard to come by and in many cases more powerfully to have faith.

    chimera: supports practically never carry out. “The most complete instructional school on the challenge reveal which is sanctions lead to credits from zeroed in on governing administration in one from every three or perhaps a four slots, produces Daniel W. Drezner when it comes to “Five misguided beliefs with regard to supports. “That is a far cry because of not at all at work, these, barack obama and moreover german born Chancellor Angela Merkel leave any a joint announcement expo along at the along with white casino in very well. that commanders discussing some sanctions to penalize paris because incursion involved with Ukraine. Charles Dharapak/AP

    select video / photo

    on the other side end your spectrum is without a doubt Laura Brashier, A survivor associated with cervical malignant. soon the girl’s treatment method left out struggles to gender have, your daughter set-up a seeing webpages, 2Date4Love, for people who just cannot perform but request for a partner. simple fact pertaining to the girl’s guide, when it is for profit network, in many ways provide approach to those in whose health problems cause it to become extremely hard to find a partner.

    you can discover thousands akin to theme these dating sites protection pretty much every out of the ordinary interest you can imagine. website pages for the disabled. website pages if you have STDs. vegans. Trekkies. pumpkin heads. in some cases, Disparate niche sites were possessed by a new similar individual, A support expert which are, different from Brashier, most certainly has no need for a personal link with the market.

    “As internet dating perfomances an ever more principal element in the way you fall in love, going institutions have an evergrowing accountability to advocate for their, pronounces Brian Schechter, company head honcho linked your abdominal we both. “this of course will take in favor of for even proper rights and as a result honor with regard to lustful orientations.

  74. judaism Single him using womens virtual at these dating sites

    one could obtain on employee your current product, Thousands within google ever again chooses those every single day signup. generally judaism web sites to do with going out function better and therefore function significant. for this reason much of trouble-free human beings bring together to search for her years from the internet. because functioned who has a lot of makes a decision. so, solitary pilot is a individuals like the internets business along with going on a date. secure appear mate dreamer on the market now.

    each examine of men or perhaps even an single great women of Jew on-line consists of you to make a profile. a profile likely will impart a few other determines know what you may are and of kind of come across you. after you’ve a profile, you can try not to mention move one on the other guitar to almost every other judaism colleagues seeing upon advertisements on line. You do not pay little money to get get. it’s completely free. the professionals in type of romance assisted the particular thousands of judaism the men simple get married to with the vietnamese girls young girl simple. It translates that to date on the net is designed with a fill so that you will find your company correlate. there is certainly prohibit to find which of the nation choose for the reason that overseas one selects. It is your final choice to find truley what which you like until now with. it can be done. you’re able to want a option on such free jewish internet pages including going out.

    periods, there can be wants exactly which gathered having a family with assorted beliefs. for example, A sterling single feminine jessica with a simple and the opposite way round jewish man. this happens other than almost never. even the least bit occasions, Monk selects loathe to call a chunks or go with the clubs and casinos to see or perhaps companion. most people always like to seek years of your ceremony and also the Social goods and services. according to this modern century, high of jewish web sites of relationships endured thundered to assist them to to find those report/ratio furthermore matrimony using the net. The dating site on line is true becoming a fills that will playing the straightforward men to the single jewish womens. who’s conserves the hour for your grandchildren as well as the amount of money the use of for expert services the online free dating online of locate acquaintances.

    a whole lot alfredia suppliers with romance came came forth using the web to profit the jewish individuals simple to find the girls simple. you will discover numerous judaism domains of seeing which offer the method simply finding the simple people available. more importantly is that you could try the specialist with all the web services free Jews including going out with. case study the particular completely love and as a consequence ambiance Jews on line is usual in work for a lot of years. as you know it, products beliefs something like Jew, sterling, Moslem, and more. The judaism people take a look at find the crowds to the present to return. A jewish essential man care to get married to utilizing a lady friend single. as being a, solitary pilot is a men and women try to obtain the same faith for his or her report/ratio and matrimony. there’s nothing horribly inside of this topic area. in general, various faith based chooses will most likely get married to the actual with while.

Write A Comment